Light Wave

Lifestyle

On Medicare, a Retired Couple Was Facing $135 a Month More for the Same Medigap Coverage. So They Switched Insurers. Now: “That’s a Win‑Win”

By Erica Coleman · November 20, 2026

For one retired couple, this year’s Medigap renewal notice was bad enough that they picked up the phone.

“Welcome back to Still Kicking and Keeping It Real. I’m Pamps,” he says at the start of a video on his YouTube channel, @StillKickingKeepingItReal. “Today I want to follow up on the video that I did a couple weeks ago on Medicare 2027.”

Pamps and his wife both carry a Medigap supplement, the private policies that help pay costs Original Medicare leaves behind. In 2026, their coverage came through AARP. “We in 2026 had our policy through AARP,” he says. With that program, he explains, UnitedHealthcare was “your only option, the only provider.”

Then the 2027 premiums arrived.

“When we got our premium for 2027,” he says, “the premium was going to go up for me alone $70 a month for the very same thing.” His wife’s was set to rise by $65 a month. “So that’s a hundred and thirty five dollars a month.”

He had heard about AMAC, the Association of Mature American Citizens, and called. He says he already knew he wanted Plan G, for foreign travel coverage on trips planned in 2027 and protection from excess charges above what Medicare pays, and he stresses that viewers’ needs may differ.

There was a step that matters for anyone thinking of doing the same. “He came back and of course he asked us the questions. Do we smoke?” Pamps says. “Do we have this illness?” Both he and his wife answered the health questions and were offered new policies through Aflac.

His own numbers moved the right way. “I was paying in 2026 $181.14,” he says. “And now through Aflac, that’s the provider through AMAC there, was gonna be $177.11.” Instead of a $70 increase, his premium went down. His verdict on that: “That’s a win-win.” He says his wife’s new premium also came in about $7 a month lower than what she paid in 2026.

Add up the increases they avoided and the small drops, and he lands on one figure. “That’s a hundred and fifty one dollars a month we’re saving that’s going into our pockets, our checkbook,” he says. By his math, that’s about $1,812 a year, and he says the phone call took about 30 minutes.

That health-questions step is the catch. According to Medicare.gov, everyone gets a one-time, 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period that starts the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. During that window, an insurer can’t refuse to sell you a policy or charge you more for pre-existing health problems. Outside of it, Medicare.gov says, you may pay more, have fewer choices, and an insurer can deny you a policy if you don’t meet its medical underwriting requirements.

That also means the fall Medicare Open Enrollment Period, which Pamps notes runs Oct. 15 through Dec. 7, does not by itself give you a right to switch Medigap policies. Medicare.gov’s page on changing Medigap policies says that in most cases you won’t have a federal right to switch unless you’re in your initial 6-month window or have a guaranteed issue right. Some states add their own protections, so it’s worth checking with your State Insurance Department.

If you’re thinking about shopping your own policy, compare the same plan letter across companies and ask how the new insurer underwrites before you apply. Medicare.gov also describes a 30-day free look period on a new Medigap policy and advises not canceling your old one until you’ve decided to keep the new one.

This article is for general information and is not financial, insurance or medical advice, and LightWave Reports does not endorse any insurer or organization. Pamps’ story and quotes are from his YouTube video. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.